Thanks for the response. I want to answer your questions and also revise/clarify a few things:
The noise happens most noticably between 1800 and 3400 rpm and absolutely only under a load (acceleration). At 3400, it pretty much stops.
It almost sounds like somebody is in the dash with a plastic stick beating on the plastic dash.
On the drive to work this morning (30 min or so), the ticking happened almost from the get go, but about 3 minutes from the office, it suddenly stopped. It seems very random, and not related to engine temperature that I can tell.
Oil...right now it is running dino 5w30, but I am a huge believer in synthetics (don't want to start the dreaded oil debate, but personal experience...) and am switching the Pathy to Mobil1 5w30 or 10w30 at the next interval (Pathy is relatively new to me). I change dino oil every 3k miles and synthetic every 5-7500. If anybody wants to chime in on the 5w30 vs 10w30 vs 10w40 debate I'd love some advice. I live in Denver where we have a couple of weeks (total) below freezing and very few days, if any, below 0F. The Pathy is garage-kept.
Thanks to anyone who can shed some light on the noise and/or the oil...