just my 2 cents
Sounds a little steep to me, but it could be due to your area. For reference, 2 months ago I bought a 95 pathy 4door, 4x4, 6cyl 5speed, 108k on the clock, in pretty great conditions for $3300, from a dealer no less. Id say if your really set on it offer $2300 and haggle from there.
have you tried kbb.com or nada.com? i know they aren't perfect but it can give you a ballpark. Is it modded in any ways that would add or detract to the value?